Chanting to Krishna…
HOLY or HEATHEN?
By Carol Moriel
” Hare Krsna Hare Krsna Krsna Krsna Hare
Hare Hare Rama Hare Rama Rama Rama Hare Hare.”
“But when ye pray, use not vain
repetitions, as the heathen do: for they think that they shall be heard for
their much speaking”- Jesus Christ (Mat. 6:7).
Hare Krishnas try to work off their bad deeds, saying, “If
you act nicely and perform pious activities then you get good fortune, and if
you act sinfully then you have to suffer. Q. What is the duty of a person who
does not believe the scriptures? A. His duty is to go to hell. Q. How can it be
changed for him? A. By coming here and chanting Hare Krishna.” (Back to Godhood,
No. 35).
Hare Krishnas carry a row of 108 rosary beads, chanting a
“round” per bead 16 times a day. They show devotion to Krishna by wearing East
Indian dress, often painting their faces. Males shave their heads except for a
hair-tuft. Sexual attention given to one’s mate is held in check to once a
month. What bondage!
ISKCON publications (the Bhagavad-Gita, As It Is, and Back
to Godhead), are sold while chanting on city streets. Hare Krishnas are to avoid
newspapers and other publications (a mind control technique). The public often
reacts to the transcendental trickery, fraudulent con games! The Hare Krishnas
consider non-members to be demons! Misleading a demon is acceptable; so they try
to liberate people’s money which is considered to be Krishna’s. Christianity
renounces dishonesty (2 Cor. 4:2). . Hare Krishnas (like New Age religion) is
just repackaged Hinduism. Hinduism teaches that many gods exist (polytheism),
that god is all and all is god. One supreme personality of the universe contains
all of the gods and goddesses within himself. The sect teaches that Krishna is
the supreme god. Followers hope to attain god-consciousness, giving up the
illusion of individuality, merging with the all-encompassing person of Krishna.
What a breath-taking leap of logic! Clearly, if I am
striving for this god-consciousness, I can never say, “I have reached
god-consciousness.” As soon as I say “I”, I have disproved my claim, for I am
still an individual personality. If I even think “I” (or think at all), I
perform an individual act of personality. Logically followed, the experience of
Nirvana becomes a non-experience experienced by a nonentity. This is impossible.
Are the Hare Krishnas compatible with
Christianity as they claim? No one can fall for their belief system and still
have a modicum of sense when it comes to the Bible. There is nothing Christian
about their belief system. The one God of the Bible (Isaiah 43:10) is
distinct from His creation (Romans 1:20-23) and condemns idol worship (Isaiah
44:6-20). We will never become a part of God or God — the job is already taken!
(See Gen. 3:1-5; Ez. 28:2-9; Isaiah 47:8-11). The Hare Krishnas believe in the
existence of Jesus but only as one person who had religious truth. He was just
one son of god and did not die for our sins. How wrong!
Anyone who comes to know Jesus Christ as God the Son (John
20:28,31), knows God is not a mere cosmic force or an impersonal spiritual
entity! How does one attain salvation? Hare Krishnas imagine salvation is gained
by working hard to erase the debts of ones karmic existence. They strive to meet
Krishna’s approval, serving and worshipping him. When good deeds atone for bad
deeds, then a person becomes one with Krishna and ceases the cycle of rebirths.
This karma idea is neither logical nor Biblical. Is it
just or reasonable for one to suffer in this life for sins committed in a
previous life that a person does not even remember? How can suffering for an
unknown sin reform the sinner so he no longer performs that sin? That would be
cruelty, not justice! Children, for example, supposedly starve because of their
bad karma in a previous life.
Is salvation from many lives of ignorant slavery? You don’t
have to chant to please God. God wants to free you from the bondage of your past
(John 8:34-36). He offers you salvation immediately (Heb. 7:25), through His
grace and not our good works (Eph. 2:8-10), and by God’s work not ours (John
6:29). You are not bound by bad karma. God knows that you could never do enough
to reach Him on your own. That is why God sent His Son, Jesus Christ, to pay for
your sin-debt at the cross. You can have peace with God right now and know that
He loves you! Accepting Jesus, God promises you can know you are accepted by Him
(1 John 5:13). God offers you forgiveness now for all of your sins and for all
time.
Can you trust a self-authenticating
message? Everything from demonism, Eastern mysticism, Roman Catholicism — the
isms, the cisms, the asims and spasms claim mystical experiences. Hare Krishna
interpretations come from Hindu philosophy. Even the Charismatic lunatic
fringe has wild experiences that resemble demonism. Everyone who carries on like
a bonzo in public places is going to be considered a bit crazy (1 Cor. 14:23).
Clearly, if you want to know what is going on, subjective religious experiences
cannot be self-interpreting. Hindu groups generally disapprove of alcohol and
drugs, but they produce the same kind of a dependency as the chanting and
meditation. Such vain efforts to attain god-consciousness really hinder getting
to know the true God. Is “inner harmony” a test of truth? Many claim peace when
there is no inner peace. Nothing appears to be more at rest than a corpse!
Relief from stress does not prove someone is close to God.
Those who study human nature know the dangers of getting rid of rationality,
grasping a pseudo-peace. Eastern Mysticism implies there is no significance in
human reason. Our minds and responsibility become enemies one must transcend to
find peace. Yet, the only lasting peace and fulfilment does make sense and is
consistent with rationality. Is a subjective human experience sufficient grounds
upon which to build our knowledge of God? The Christian life does include
wonderful experiences; but trusting the God who spoke in history is not just
subjective. Objectively, Jesus Christ came as God’s personal, revelation. Jesus
called men into a personal relationship with God through knowing Him (John 1:18;
14:7).
Is meditation and chanting desirable
to reach out to God? Bhakti-Yoka is not of God! Jesus never encouraged this kind
of meditation. Instead He taught His disciples to pray. The prayer He
taught was simple, rational and short. Bible characters experienced God’s
blessings through their daily experiences and devotion to Him. Jesus warned that
ecstatic experiences are not the criteria to discern a person’s relationship
with God (Mat. 7:22). Love for God is defined in practical terms (John
14:23-24). If there were any value in mind-emptying or mantra-rehearsing, Jesus
would have said so.
Can we ignore the possibilities of spiritual deception?
(Mat. 7:15; 24:11; 2 Pet. 2:1; 1 John 4:1-3). Besides God, there is another
spiritual power, a deceiver and a liar (John 8:44). Satan gives experiences to
religious people all over the world. Meditation and mantra-chanting result in a
loss of personality and psychological disorder. Satan busily exploits the
Eastern meditative techniques! Just opening up gives him access to the mind. In
human terms, psychiatrists note a similarity between what they call a
manic-depressive psychosis and those who practice mystical experiences. The
Bible always interprets such personality disorders in terms of direct action
from the devil who devours human personality (Luke 8:30). Unlike the Hindu
philosophical presuppositions, your human individuality is very important to God
(Mat. 13:43; 20:23; 25:23; 1 Cor. 15:35-55; 1 Thes. 5:23; 2 Tim. 4:18).
How can we know the true God? We must come to God as a
Person we need to know (John 14:7). Such knowledge is not mystical; it is
personal. This knowledge bridges the gap between the objective and the
subjective. God reveals Himself to us both objectively, through the Bible (1
Pet. 1:23), and subjectively, through His Spirit (John 3:5). An intellectual
understanding of the Bible is important but not enough. God’s Word appears
puzzling and sterile without His Spirit. Knowing about God is not knowing God
Himself. If you treat anyone as only an object, you will never come to really
know that person. You merely know how they look or act. Subjectively, we must
come to God, knowing Him and being known (John 10:14-15; Gal. 4:9). Applying
these truths by the Spirit, we enter into a personal relationship with God (Mat.
11:25-30; 1 Cor. 2:6-16; 2 Cor. 4:6).
God is not just a fact to be believed or a feeling to be
experienced. He is a Person to be known, trusted and loved. What is the gospel
(1 Cor. 15:1) that saves (vs. 2)? We must understand, objectively, that Jesus
died for our sins, was buried and rose again from the dead (vs. 3,4).
Subjectively, the Holy Spirit must apply the truth to our hearts. There must be
repentance and faith (a change of mind and a change of heart) before becoming a
Christian. Neglecting either produces many decisions and many experiences, but
not real life in God. Spiritual experiences without God’s Word lead to an
incoherent mysticism resembling the work of evil spirits.
Therefore, if God is to be known, it will be through a
union and cooperation of external revealed truth and internal spiritual
illumination Illusions or delusions? The Hare Krishnas
refuse to eat eggs, meat, or fish (Acts 10:9-16; 1 Cor. 10:25-31; 1 Tim. 4:1-5).
Their food is considered a spiritual offering to Krishna. They are deceived into
thinking that our material atmosphere is just an illusion. Yet they
ceremoniously bath, dress, feed, and worship statues in their temple.
Regardless of anyone’s religious perspective of life after death, what happens
will not just follow the views of some religious group. Your destiny depends
upon reality!
Is the Koran a divine book? Hare Krishnas regard both the
Bible and the Koran as distorted scripture. Relating to prophecy, the Koran
contains only one and that was self-fulfilling by Mohammed (not too impressive).
We might score the Koran a .001 on that basis.
What about the Bible? Hundreds of prophecies given hundreds
of years in advance have been fulfilled (no failures)! In baseball terms, the
Bible bats a thousand!
Poof or Proof? When it’s all said and done, facts still
count. You can chant yourself right into hell or you can investigate
objectively! Read the greatest Book ever written! It will touch your heart and
stimulate your intellect! If your religion is wrong, you are wrong for all
eternity! It would be well to take time now and hear from God! Consider Science
for example ............
God’s Word, The Bible Says.....
“In the beginning God created…” (Gen. 1:1). A termite chews and swallows wood; but cannot digest it! Flagellates (parasites living in the stomach of the termite) digest cellulose fibers if someone chews it up first. The termite is totally dependent on the flagellate and the flagellates are totally dependent on the termite! One cannot exist without the other. Explain that without creation!
Says the life of flesh is in the blood (Lev. 17:11).
Describes the fixed orbit of the earth (Job 22:14).
Says the earth is suspended on nothing. Atlas, a huge
turtle or elephants do not hold it up. In the Northern sky within millions of
stars is a vast expanse of blackness. Only God could describe it before
telescopes (Job 26:7).
Noted that the air has weight (the result of gravity).
Science confirms air is about 50 miles thick, exactly right to support life and
perfect for our lungs. Air filters deadly rays. If the earth was 10% larger or
smaller we would all die. We are in a fragile balance before the sun between
frying and freezing (Job 28:25).
Explains the hydraulic cycle. Condensation and hydrology
maintain life, provide evaporation, trans-portation, precipitation and run-off.
The never-ending cycle is described with fine accuracy (Job 36:27-28; Ec. 1:6,7;
Isaiah 40:12; 55:10).
Shows the earth rotates (Job 38:12-17).
Tells of the treasures of the snow. Snow provides nitrogen
for fertilizer. Each flake is perfect and different, (Job 38:22).
Describes ice. Uniquely, frozen water expands and rises; to
sink would kill the waterlife (Job 38:30).
Explains the solar system. The Hebrew language speaks of a
pivot or hinge. In the south-southwest is the Pleiades, 7 stars making up the
center of the solar system (Job 38:31).
Describes man near a dinosaur (Job 40:15-24).
Mentions the paths of the sea (Psalm 8:8).
Reveals that the earth is wearing down. Now mankind affirms
the speed of light is decaying, the magnetic field is collapsing, the earth is
slowly beginning to wobble on its axis, and the protective ozone layer is
thinning. Could nothing plus nobody result in everything, bringing man from a
frog? The 2nd law of thermo-dynamics says everything tends to disintegrate, not
move to a higher complexity (Psalm 102:25,26).
Describes poetically the DNA molecule in the formation of
the unborn child (Psalm 139:13-16).
Mentions the dust particles in the air. Without reflection
on dust there could be no light (Proverbs 8:26).
Explains psychotherapy (Proverbs 16:24; 17:22).
Tells us the wind has currents. Science discovered that the
circulation of winds move by fixed laws. Scripture is not human supposition (Ec.
1:6; Isaiah 40:12).
Explains the ocean as the origin of rain (Ec. 1:7).
Tells us the earth is not flat but a round sphere. The
atmosphere is a terrestrial blanket making the earth inhabitable — retaining
heat, spreading light, and providing air (Isaiah 40:22).
Explains that the stars are beyond numbering. Hipparchus
numbered the stars in 150 B.C. at exactly 1026. Ptolemy, 150 years later,
counted 1056 . There are at least 10 million, billion, billion stars according
to Dr. Henry Morris. Scientists estimate by modern telescope that there are 100
billion stars in our galaxy alone. Note that there are not millions but billions
of such galaxies. Biblical insights were far in advance of our modern day
science (Gen. 15:5; Jeremiah 33:32; Job 22:12; Isaiah 55:9; 1 Corinthians 15:41
and 2 Peter 3:10).
| From a theological perspective, Hare Krishna
devotees are classified as practitioners of Bhakti Yoga. They are also
referred to as Gaudiya Vaishnavas because they follow a line of gurus
descending from Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, who appeared in Bengal (Gauda is
an old name of Bengal). Vaishnavism comes under the general banner of
being a Hindu religion. In terms of general diet among Gaudiya Vaishnavas, meat, fish, eggs, onions, garlic, and mushrooms are avoided due to their purportedly adverse effects on the consciousness of the eater. The Hare Krishna Movement was the subject of a number of academic studies. Today it is accepted by the academics as "the most genuinely Hindu of all the many Indian movements in the West". Not only Hindus or brahmanas were instrumental in the early appearance and spread of Hare Krishna movement in the 16th century. Haridasa Thakura, for example, was born outside of Hindu tradition but is considered the most famous convert of Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, apart from Rupa Goswami and Sanatana Goswami themselves, and the story of his heroism in the face of torture is told in Chaitanya Charitamrta, Antya lila |
--------------------------------------------